Irish soccer
 

The SPL’s death has been quick, and it’s no less painful for that

Celtic reached the Uefa Cup final in 2003. Rangers did the same five years later. This season, the pair have gone nine European group games without a victory, and other SPL sides have been embarrassed by some of the continent’s lesser lights. So are we witnessing the quick, painful death of Scottish football?
 
     By Shane Breslin
     27 November 2009, 5:09:47 PM
 
It’s not long ago that Scottish Premier League sides were rubbing shoulders with Europe’s best but with television money having dried up and the top sides in seemingly irrevocable decline, Scottish football increasingly resembles the old aristocrat without an arse in his trousers.

Rewind a couple of years, and the vista was so different, with Gordon Strachan courting acclaim after leading Celtic to the knock-out stages of the Champions League in successive seasons.

Strachan’s achievements were a scarcely expected improvement on the excellent record of Martin O’Neill, who guided the Bhoys to the Uefa Cup final in 2003 and helped to establish a dazzling record at Parkhead.

The 2001/02 season was Celtic’s first in the group stages of Europe’s top competition and, spurred on by the famed Parkhead roar, they won all three games in Glasgow against Juventus, Porto and Rosenborg.

In time, their failings would be on their travels but there was no sign of that during the run to the 2003 Uefa Cup final, where they beat Blackburn and Liverpool away and went to Portugal for the semi-final second leg against Boavista and took the win they needed to book a date with Porto.

Even that final, an unforgettable night when 40,000 happy Celts descended on Seville, underlined Celtic’s status as a side which could compare itself favourably with the best in Europe. Porto, whose success in lifting the Champions League trophy 12 months later was founded on Jose Mourinho’s characteristic defensive solidity, emerged on top, but only on a 3-2 scoreline after extra-time.

Over the next five years, Lyon, Manchester United, Benfica twice, AC Milan all left Parkhead chastened.

Rangers, too, have made their own splashes on European competition. By far their best campaign was 2007/08, when their Champions League results included a 3-0 win in Lyon – that’s three-nil, away to the French champions.

They failed to reach the last 16 but, parachuted into the Uefa Cup as the group’s third-placed side, went all the way to the final, knocking out Werder Bremen, Sporting Lisbon and Fiorentina before their defensive game-plan came up just short against an Andrei Arshavin-inspired Zenit St Petersburg.

Rangers and Celtic are the standard-bearers for Scottish football but all across the SPL this past 12 months, there has been ruin.

The gaping chasm between football in England and Scotland, non-existent when Celtic were regularly overcoming Premiership opposition five or six years ago, was all too evident when the Bhoys were outclassed over two legs by Arsenal in a Champions League qualification play-off.

Rerouted to the Europa League, Tony Mowbray’s side have been singularly dismal, taking just two points from their four games to date. Failure to overcome group leaders Hapoel Tel Aviv at Parkhead next Wednesday will end their European interest for this season. Even if they manage to extricate themselves from their current predicament – and that is all too unlikely – it is impossible to ignore the apathy of their fans: Parkhead, routinely shaken to its core on big European nights in the recent past, was less than two-thirds full for the visit of Hamburg last month.

As for Rangers, well, move along please. Nothing to see here. A 4-1 home defeat to Sevilla was bad enough but when it was followed by the same scoreline against unknowns Unirea Urziceni, the deathknell sounded on Scottish football.

Look below the Old Firm, and there is almost no reason for optimism. Motherwell lost a Europa League first leg to Llanelli in the summer. They were able to redeem themselves in the second leg there but bowed out after a 6-1 aggregate defeat to Steaua Bucharest.

A 4-0 first leg defeat did for Hearts against Dinamo Zagreb. Even worse, Falkirk lost to Vaduz (they’re from Liechtenstein). More contemptible still, Aberdeen went down 8-1 to the might of Sigma Olomouc, themselves spanked by Everton next time out.

With those results, the SPL’s Uefa co-efficient will slide inexorably in the future. The Scottish League was in the top 10 a year ago but is listed in 13th for next season’s competitions. Should they drop outside the top 15 – and it looks certain that they will – their number of Champions League slots will be reduced from two to one.

Where will it end? With the demise of Setanta Sports, Scottish clubs must now budget for greatly reduced earnings in television revenue.

On the financial side of things, Celtic remain prudently run – too much so for the liking of many fans spoiled by success – but will not countenance the level of spending necessary to arrest the slide, never mind build towards bridging the gap to the elite. It is all too conceivable that Strachan, whose popularity with the Celtic fans was never more than lukewarm, could see the direction in which the club was headed, and Mowbray is shouldering the burden of being in charge when the whole thing unravels.

However unsatisfied Celtic fans may be, they can be thankful that they’re not Rangers; the Ibrox side is much worse off. There were reports last month that their lenders would consider placing the club in administration due to debts which are estimated at £30m. Indeed, Rangers were effectively deemed worthless, with the bank seeking the sale of the club at precisely the amount of its existing loans.

And yet, the Old Firm still dominates the domestic league. They are first and second going into this weekend, like they have been almost every weekend for years.

Dwarfed by their rivals, none of the chasing pack – not Hibernian or Dundee United, for all their promise, not traditionally proud Aberdeen, not the shambles that is Hearts – is in a position to take advantage.

So what’s the opposite of a rising tide lifting all boats?

Comments:  (Click here to post your comment)
1
Who gives a fiddler’s?
 
Donal - 6:22:21 PM, 11/27/2009  
Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

2
I don’t think you can so assuredly say Scottish football is dead one year after Rangers made the Uefa cup final. The league is not going to be ever one of Europe’s elite nor will the Old Firm be considered two of Europe’s stronger sides ever again due to the financial aspect of the modern game, but the league has a strong fan base, a great heritage, and with the old firm receding in power other teams such as Hibs and Dundee United may make the league less predicable. Oh, and Donal, I give a fiddler’s and so do the thousands of Irish soccer supporters both at home and abroad that follow the SPL, as Raffa Benitez would say, these are the facts.
 
jaffa - 6:47:05 PM, 11/27/2009  
Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

3
i dont think you should be gloating too much about the state of scottish soccer
look closer to home and see the mess
of last season we call the league of ireland or is the eircom league, by the way i am not a bar stool supporter of the english premier league i have
supported my club dundalk f.c for the past 50 years.
 
clonlee dundalk - 7:14:13 PM, 11/27/2009  
Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

4
"Who cares?" must surely be one of the most ridiculous posts on any blog. If you don’t care, p*** off and leave the comment to those of us who do.

A little bit dramatic - I think there was still a substantial gap 5 or 6 years ago.

Mowbray appears to be out of his depth. Never mind telling us who he can’t afford, how about making the best of what he’s got for starters. He doesn’t know his best side. In fact, as a former centre-back, it’s worrying that he’s unsure as to who his strongest centre back pairing is, after nearly four months of the season.

He’s a nice bloke, impossible to dislike and he’s coped admirably with the cruel hand he was dealt with the death of his wife. He’s clearly a man of integrity, too. But being a nice bloke just isn’t enough and I’m not impressed by his purchases so far.

I think he’ll struggle to last longer than a season at Parkhead.
 
KentHoops - 7:32:20 PM, 11/27/2009  
Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

5
It would be interesting after the barely polite rebuff that the Old Firm got from the Premier League about their potential gatecrashing to see where the SPL goes.

I would suggest that a move to summer football could help, especially when looking at the truly dismal Europe results of the last year or two.

A bigger problem seems to be that Scotland are no longer producing players of a high calibre. Would Kris Boyd or Kenny Miller be a regular starter for any EPL side? Fletcher at Burnley looks a useful player, Gordon is a decent keeper and we could yet witness a career progression from Alan Hutton but this is a nation that produced Baxter, Souness, Dalglish, Hansen, Gemmill, Johnstone and the like.

Ask yourself when was the last time Scotland produced a player of the quality of a McAllister, McCoist, McStay or John Collins?
 
Gerry1371 - 8:13:32 PM, 11/27/2009  
Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

6
Note: This comment has been deleted by the moderators.
 
- 8:39:32 PM, 11/27/2009  


7
Note: This comment has been deleted by the moderators.
 
- 11:16:44 PM, 11/27/2009  


8
Administrator can you message Gerry and tell him the error. How is that possible?
 
Jaffa - 12:19:38 AM, 11/28/2009  
Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

9
Administrator can you message Gerry again. I expect that an error of that magatude would get his attention - considering the fact that I work with him every day.
 
Jaffa - 1:28:54 PM, 11/28/2009  
Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

10
Error?
 
Gerry1371 - 9:35:30 PM, 11/28/2009  
Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

11
"the shambles that is Hearts" is the last team to split the OF - just three seasons ago. It’s also the team that finished third last season. If Hearts are a shambles, and in some ways they are off the field and are having a poor season so far this year (but, hey, so are teams like Everton in the EPL), then what does that make the rest of the teams?
 
Stu - 5:31:47 PM, 11/30/2009  
Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

12
Gerry, someone is making comments on this thread under my name. I apologise.
 
jaffa - 1:03:07 AM, 1/12/2009  
Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

13
scottish football looks like its screwed but its growing, the smaller sides are starting to grow into potential title threats

look at hibs? mauled celtic on the 1st game against us this season.. dundee united have impressed alot lately.. motherwell has a young squad but seem to be slowly turning into a threat..

yeah the spl looks like its gowing nowhere but down the bog... its just that now the smaller ones are catching up.. and the european thing?? since when do other scottish teams really have much of a chance to establish themselves in europe anyway??? its always been a celtic/rangers domination in scotland since aberdeen had thier glory days

im a celtic supporter but a 2 horse race between us and smiths orc army of mordor is just plain boring now... especially when neither are playing good football..

it would be good to see teams like hibs, dundee united, motherwell, the sheepshaggers and hearts scare the big 2 for a bit and win some trophies.

thats my opinion anyway.
 
TheBigRightBack - 12:47:26 PM, 1/29/2010  
Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

 
Post your comment:
  
Name:
Insert below word into text-box
(What is this?)
  
Comment:
 
  more blogs
   McCarthy marked out by old head on young shoulders (9)
   Would another change of format benefit the League of Ireland? (17)
   Transfer deadline day as it happened (21)
   Scot-free Celtic on one-way ticket to nowhere (85)
   Trap trek: the next generation (26)
   Pantomime villain Tevez masks United’s real enemies (3)
   Bohs’ Fenlon stance to be applauded (15)
   Insurance vultures paint past in warm glow (4)
   Delaney parting shot puts league in the spotlight (9)
   The Cup is reeling from a decade of mortal blows (8)
   McCarthy was wrong to dress Wolves in sheep’s clothing (20)
   Threesome: Half-way line specials (5)
   Fergie: greatest of all time? (14)
   English triumphalism reminds us all of the real enemy (44)
   Embracing progress would be Fifa’s best compensation (13)
   Threesome: Sepp Blatter furores (5)
   The 33rd team request is beyond laughable (64)
   The SPL’s death has been quick, and it’s no less painful for that (13)
   Will Darron Gibson make the grade at Manchester United? (19)
   Spare a thought for Big Mick (19)
   Hand of Gaul – the fall-out continues (25)
   Paris 2009: Our turn to deal with sporting injustice (36)
   Dignity lies in avoiding England’s Hand of God mistakes (19)
   France-Ireland – the player ratings (56)
   Ireland can be inspired by Arsenal’s Anfield shock (19)
   France v Ireland – Live build-up (14)
   Get over it, Stephen. We have (28)
   Ireland v France – player ratings (30)
   Ireland v France: Live build-up blog (32)
   Dropping axe on Derry could be a turning-point (20)
   League hits new low as PFAI promise “all-out strike” (20)
   Is Galway capable of supporting Tribal Trio? (15)
   Can Miller rediscover lost promise? (9)
   Keane aura shattered by identikit errors (21)
   Levelling of Premier League’s playing field is something to savour (9)
   World Cup play-off draw - live blog (98)
   Feeling bleu... (23)
   Ireland v Montenegro – player ratings (26)
   RTE’s crew in cuckoo-land (40)